![]()
A few weeks back, i wrote about my relative’s encounter with hard sell tactics at a beauty salon. Curious to know if her experience was commonplace, i turned to CASE for information. CASE is the consumer watchdog in Singapore whose mission is to inform, educate and protect consumers. I started my email with a brief description of the encounter followed by a list of questions.
Their replies, though polite, left me slightly puzzled. I’ve extracted my questions and their replies here. I’ve not revised the words.
Beauty industry covers a very wide area…
I have some questions which i hope you (or your colleague) would be able to help clarify:
1. What does “beauty industry” comprise of?
Answer: Beauty Industry covers a very wide area.
2. Do you have the figure for the number of complaints for the beauty industry for 2005-2006 or even figures prior to 2004-2005?
3. The website did not show a breakdown of the types of complaints by industry. I’m most interested to know what the majority of the complaints for beauty industry are.
Answer for 2 & 3: We regret that we are unable to provide this information,would like to seek your understanding in this matter.
4. Is there a “black list” for companies in the beauty industry and can CASE release the names of those companies should the public want to know?
Answer: We do not have a list of blacklist companies.
5. What is the difference between “to make a false claim” and “making false claims about a product”?
Answer: to make false claims is about to make it and making a false claims, its in process of making a false claims.
6. “cooling off period” constitutes the biggest share of unfair trade practices but i’m not entirely sure what it meant.
Answer: Under the Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act, the 3-day cooling off period is only application to 2 industries, Timeshare and uninvited Direct Sales (Door-to-Door). As for other industries, it’s based on the goodwill of the vendor to extend it to their customer.
We regret that we are unable to provide this information…
As you may have guessed, i wasn’t too enlightened. I followed up with these questions and was rewarded with yet another polite and somewhat familiar reply.
Thanks for replying to my queries.
For 2) & 3), is it because
a) the information was not compiled for 2005-2006;
b) they are being compiled and may be released by CASE later; or
c) they are available but can’t be released to me or any member of the public?
I understand that such statistics are compiled by CASE annually and i’ve seen them mentioned in news reports.
Answer: Thank you for your reply. We regret that we are unable to provide any information. You can refer to our website:- www.case.org.sg. If need to reveal it would be in our website. We need to seek your understanding in this matter.